| Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... |
A significant body of research, spearheaded by Dr. Murray Straus, a respected sociologist and co-director of the Family Research Lab at the University of New Hampshire, raises critical concerns about the practice of spanking children. His extensive studies over four decades reveal that spanking not only impairs cognitive development but also increases the likelihood of antisocial and criminal behavior in later life.
In his influential book, The Primordial Violence, Dr. Straus synthesizes findings from more than 7,000 American families and a comprehensive 32-nation study, illustrating the pervasive effects of physical punishment across cultures. The book offers compelling evidence that parents often resort to spanking for reasons that extend beyond mere correction of misbehavior, emphasizing the need for a more informed approach to discipline.
While spanking children may seem to address immediate behavioral issues, research indicates that it is no more effective than alternative disciplinary methods, such as time-outs, verbal explanations, or loss of privileges. Importantly, the potential benefits of spanking come with significant drawbacks. Dr. Straus points out that this practice can weaken the bond between parent and child and increase the risk that children will resort to violence against peers and intimate partners in adulthood. Additionally, it can hinder mental development and negatively impact academic performance.
Dr. Straus highlights that over 100 studies corroborate these findings, with an overwhelming consensus among researchers regarding the harmful effects of spanking children. “There is likely no other area of parenting where research results are so consistently aligned,” he notes.
Alongside Dr. Straus, co-authors Emily Douglas, an associate professor of social work, and Rose Anne Medeiros, a quantitative methodologist, advocate for policy changes aimed at eliminating spanking as a disciplinary method. They propose initiatives such as public service announcements promoting non-violent parenting, health warnings accompanying birth certificates, and resources for parents facing challenges with their children. Each chapter of The Primordial Violence discusses practical and policy implications to support these changes.
Key findings of the effects of spanking children from the book include:
- Positive Outcomes of Non-Physical Discipline: Research shows that avoiding spanking fosters better interpersonal skills and promotes higher academic achievement.
- The Correlation Between Spanking Children and Behavioral Issues: The book illustrates a clear link between spanking and subsequent behavioral problems, including increased tendencies toward crime.
- Trends in Disciplinary Practices: Despite growing evidence against the efficacy of spanking, many parents continue to use it, highlighting the need for ongoing education and advocacy.
Dr. Straus offers a thoughtful suggestion for families during the holiday season: “If you’re seeking a gift that will enhance your child’s chances of a fulfilling and healthy life—one that includes career success and a peaceful marriage—consider the commitment to refrain from spanking. Sharing this promise with your children is likely to enhance their respect and affection for you, while also helping you uphold this commitment.”
Globally, there is a shifting paradigm regarding corporal punishment, with over 20 countries now prohibiting spanking. This emerging consensus underscores the belief that children have a fundamental right to be free from physical discipline. The United Nations is actively advocating for all nations to abolish spanking, recognizing that refraining from such practices not only diminishes the risks of delinquency and mental health issues but also affirms children’s rights to safety and dignity—rights that adults have increasingly come to recognize over the past century.
Dr. Straus is widely regarded as a leading researcher in this field, having studied spanking among diverse and representative samples of American parents since 1969. His work has garnered numerous accolades, including recognition as a Life Fellow of the International Society for Research in Aggression and as a Fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. He has presided over several scientific societies, including the National Council on Family Relations, and has advised institutions such as the National Institutes of Health and the National Science Foundation. An accomplished author, Dr. Straus has published over 200 research articles and 15 books, including Beating the Devil Out of Them: Corporal Punishment in American Families and Its Effects on Children.
For further insights and access to much of his research on the implications of spanking, visit Dr. Straus’s dedicated website.
